When winter is on its way, it's time to get the right clothes and footwear to withstand the snow and freezing temperatures. Not only do you have to deal with ice, but rain, sleet, and slush are typical occurrences over the following season.

As such, you'll need to wear the best rubber boots during the winter and on any rainy day.

Bogs Boots and Muck Boots make some of the best rubber boots out there.

If you've decided to purchase some rain boots for the winter season, then it's clear you have two main options to choose from.

A pair of rubber rain boots will keep your feet nice and warm during the coldest and wettest of days. Keep reading to learn the differences and features of Muck Boots versus Bogs in our guide below.

Features of Muck Boots and Bogs

  • 10 inches in height
  • A top circumference of 14.5 inches
  • Heel and toe reinforcement
  • Breathable air mesh lining material
  • Fleece lining
  • Flex-foam neoprene insulation
  • Extended rubber overlay for the upper material
  • Reinforced, heavy-duty traction sole
  • The back of the Muck boot has a silver reflective stripe
  • Height of 13.5 inches
  • Top circumference of 13.5 inches
  • 9-mm ThermoPlus inner boot that is removable and washable
  • A rubber upper portion of the boot
  • Stretchy fabric
  • Non-slip rubber outsole that includes traction
  • Comfort rated from temperate to cold conditions

Next, we will discuss the design of each type of boot to show you the quality and benefits of each of these boots in terms of how well they will protect your feet.

It is possible to find some exceptionally warm rubber boots to wear on cold and snowy winter days. 

Description of the Boot Designs

Here, we will discover the qualities and workmanship of each type of rubber rain boot. We will go over the stability and material of each pair of boots to see how well they would serve you in the winter. So let’s get into it!

Muck Boot

Muck boots are made out of high-quality neoprene material. This makes them relatively durable and stable. While they will wear out one day, they should remain worthy for approximately three years or longer if you don’t wear them daily.

These boots are also lightweight, easy to clean, and can withstand all sorts of environments. Muck boots are great on extremely cold days, muddy and wet ground, and rough terrain if you want to go on a hike.

Bogs Boots

Bogs are waterproof and made of treated nylon fabric. They’re insulated to keep you warm and comfortable during the colder seasons or when it's snowing. 

One negative aspect of the Bogs boots is that their material makes them somewhat uncomfortable on long walks. There is no ankle support when walking in these boots.

It does have excellent traction when walking anywhere that may be slippery. So if you have a sheet of ice outside your home or workplace in the wintertime, these boots will have great traction and keep you from falling. 


Bogs and Muck boots both have very high-quality and durable features, as their designs and the materials used are superior compared to the standard rubber rain boots.

You should be able to wear either pair of boots for several years before they become worn out. Both Bogs and Muck boots should maintain a high-quality look and feel for a few years. In particular, Muck boots should last you at least three or four years into the future. 

As for Bogs boots, the company itself guarantees a one-year period free of workmanship and material defects. As long as you keep these boots dry and make sure to dry out the interiors after a day of playing in the snow, the Bogs boots should also last for multiple years.

Weight and Fit

Since Muck boots tend to have more stretchy and flexible material, they can run a little big in terms of fit. These are perfect for people who have wider feet. However, if your feet are a bit narrow, be sure to wear a pair of thick socks before putting on a pair of Muck boots.

While Muck boots are made of lightweight material, you may, at times, find these boots somewhat heavy to wear, especially on longer walks. 

A positive of Bogs boots have a great fit, as they are spacious and easy to put on. Furthermore, the Bogs Bozeman Tall brand is actually designed to have customizable fits. 

The Bogs Classic boot fits true to size. However, they come in full sizes, and you may have trouble if you usually order half sizes for your footwear.

Some customers, however, have found that the Bogs boots have a more sloppy and loose fit, which is why you may want to add a footbed insert.


Due to the rubber material of both these rain boots, the breathability of both Muck and Bogs boots is not super effective.

Nonetheless, you can choose Muck boots that have a breathable mesh, which can increase their comfort.

While Bogs boots are waterproof and will protect your feet from the cold and snow, they are not the most comfortable when you need to go on a hike.

Nonetheless, the neoprene material and the removable, moisture-wicking insole does give Bogs boots some breathability.

Sole Grip and Traction

Muck boots tend to have a strong outsole traction pattern when it comes to sole grip and traction. This is great when you’re outdoors for much of the day, and you need to walk on rough terrain. The durable rubber outsole of Muck boots will also protect your Achilles heel and instep. 

This is different from Bogs boots that have little ankle support. Muck boots have a firm sole that can provide a good grip when walking around wet areas or amid snow or mud. 

Bogs boots have stability when walking, but they could offer your foot and ankle more support. This means Bogs boots have less traction when walking through rough terrain. Nonetheless, you should have decent traction on uneven ice as compared to other rain boots.

Based on this information, Muck boots are the best choice for a solid sole grip and better traction.


You’ll find that both Bogs boots and Muck boots have strong insulation features to keep your feet warm.

Classic Bogs boots have a Sherpa Pile snow cuff, and a ThermoPlus felt inner boot.

On the other hand, Muck boots have a fleece lining and are made out of 5-mm CR Flex-Foam neoprene material.

No matter which of these you're deciding on you can be sure you'll be choosing from among the best insulated hunting boots on the market.


The pricing of Bogs boots is the most affordable. Muck boots come at a good value but are slightly more expensive than the typical Bogs boots. However, sometimes, you’ll need to consider the quality versus price. If you want great traction, Muck boots may be a better choice.

Furthermore, the hunting-based Bogs boots can be more costly as compared to their classic pair. Regardless, the more affordable option is the Bogs boot, and this pair is relatively durable.

Bottom Line

When looking for the best pair of boots to wear this winter, the Muck boots may be the best choice.

They offer more support to the Achilles heel and ankle as well as greater traction and sole grip. 

However, they are more pricey. If you’re looking for a cheaper pair, you may want to buy Bogs boots.

Whatever choice you make, you’re sure to stay warm this winter.

For further rubber boot company comparisons check out our LaCrosse vs Muck Boots article.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *